The Verdict on Scrivener


11-8-2011 9-02-28 PMI’ve been using Scrivener for a while now, to outline my newest novel, to write something which is under wraps for a while with my buddy Bryce, and just to piddle. I imported some of my old stuff just to see what it could do. And better still, what it can’t do.

The list of cans outstretches the can’ts by a long way, but I’m completely sold on this software for a few reasons.

Ease of Use

As software goes, this one’s interface isn’t as intuitive as it might be if they conformed to the Microsoft look and feel. But this was born in MacWorld’s OS environment, and so it doesn’t have the familiar Windows program appearance. Even so, it’s not confusing. There are a couple of “getting started” kind of videos, and if you spend ten minutes with those videos, you’re going to be familiar enough with the program to accomplish anything you’d like.

The features, when you see them demonstrated in the videos, are simple, easy to use, easy to understand, and writers won’t be bogged down in them. That’s awesome.

Affordability

This is the best money I’ve ever spent on writing software, bar none, and that’s saying something. Sometimes, Microsoft Word and Text Tree are all I want, but this package combines many of the features of both. At a paltry $45, this is money well spent in my book. I’ve tried using everything from Word to WriteWay Pro to PowerWriter. And while PW has a lot of really cool features which are close to what I need, Scrivener packs them all in and does it with simplicity and ease. And it’s cheap. I’ve paid more for keyboards.

Powerful Versatility

Scrivener TemplatesScrivener has capability to be generic, specific, and even has templates for non-fiction (where were you when I needed you in 2009/2010?!). You can Google online for templates and find them out there, free of charge, from a variety of sources. I’ve downloaded one for my Hero’s Journey method (I’d already started the project with the generic novel with parts template before I thought to look for the HJ template), another for my 4-part structure, and there are others out there, I’m sure. If you want to write it, you can write it in Scrivener, and if you want to write it, someone may have a template for it.

It also does some fantastic things in ebook creation, and since I’m an indie publisher of my works on Kindle Direct Publishing, this caught my attention. The only other software I’ve seen which came close to doing this was WriteWay Pro. It’s able to export, but only to a .doc or .docx file (Word formats), which KDP allows you to upload for publication.

The problem with uploading your .doc manuscript directly, however, is the formatting may or may not come out the way you think. If it does, bonus! You win! But more Kindle authors than not don’t recommend this method. Eventually, the technology to do this will be available and we can do away with conversion software altogether. But for me, the safest way is still to convert from Word to HTML and then clean up the proprietary formatting, put it into MobiPocket Creator when I’ve done that, and then upload that .prc file, which is one of Kindle’s native formats.

Scrivener Compile EbookBut Scrivener takes care of all of that. I can import the cover image. I can insert the front matter as it’s own page. I can add any images I want to use directly into the text portions of the chapters or scenes (mostly with non-fiction, though, where illustrations and figures are common), and then I can compile the document as a .mobi (another native Kindle format) or .epub file. And the conversion, while not absolutely perfect, is so good, I uploaded one of my novellas to Kindle this way just yesterday.

As a reference point, doing it my standard way took me hours. Several. And Lord help me if I found a mistake, typo, bad formatting, or anything else. I had to do the whole upload and conversion again. But with Scrivener, I correct the typo, formatting, whatever, I save the project, I open the compile window again and everything is still there, and then I click the “Compile” button and wait. A few seconds later, my document, in .mobi format, is ready in the designated folder. I upload with confidence to Kindle.

Now that’s worth $45 to me. I’d have paid a lot more for software which can do that.

In Closing

I can’t see myself going back to anything else but good ol’ Word for writing after this. I love Word. I love how powerful it’s become. But a long document of tens of thousands of words gets unwieldy, and finding something in an earlier part is a pain. The headings and outlining structure help a lot, but Scrivener allows you to have each scene in a discreet and locatable text chunk. I love how fast it is to move around.

I love that it’s cheap. I love the videos which explain everything. I sat through a 36-minute introduction videocast which gave a more thorough explanation of the basic features, which is all a writer needs to complete a book. I did it on my cheap, crappy tablet, laying in bed, on a Sunday night. It was awesome. And when you show me how to do something, I do a lot better than someone telling me how to do it. Or making me read it.

I love that it can export to .mobi and .epub. I love that. This is my purpose anyway, and Scrivener makes it just flat-out simple to do.

With all that going for it, I can’t recommend Scrivener highly enough to writers, especially those who want to e-publish on Kindle or in other formats (the .epub is fairly universal).

-JDT-

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “The Verdict on Scrivener

  1. Now do you see why I was totally sold on Scrivener? It made formatting my ebooks super simple (with the exception of Smashwords). That alone made it worth using as my primary writing software. So yeah, hello fellow convert. Want a cookie? 😀

    No thanks, on the cookie, but…Scrivener really shines with eBook conversion to be sure. And with formatting exported manuscripts in general. I tell ya, I paid $100 for a piece of software specifically for writing and it doesn’t even come close. For writing it was great, but so is Microsoft Word. For formatting as an eBook, Word’s hard to clean up and time consuming. With my other software packages — both WriteWay Pro and Power Writer, which were each more expensive than Scrivener — I have to export to Word first (or as an RTF file) and then convert to eBook. Yuck. Scrivener is brilliant. I’m sold, and don’t think I’ll be using anything else from here out.

  2. Eeeenteresting. I haven’t written in software other than Word in ages, so I’m completely out of touch with what’s out there. I’ll keep this in mind in case my Mom turns out to be right and I do end up writing a book. (She’s sure I’ve got at least one novel in me. Then again she’s also pretty sure that I’m going to win a Nobel prize, and an OIympic gold medal, so don’t hold your breath.)

    I know you can write, but whether you want to is another matter. I seem to have the opposite problem. I want to write, but few want to read what I’ve written. Still, the software is clever and easy to use. It might take a couple of tutorials to get you going, but once you do, it’s pretty amazing. 🙂

  3. Pingback: The Verdict on Scrivener | Everything Scrivener

  4. I was drawn in by the corkboard via a screenshot long before the Windows version became available (and even bid on a few used Macs on Ebay *exclusively* for this software), but when I first tried it I hated it.

    You sound a little like I was toward it. Rather ambivalent or worse after trying it on your own. I didn’t realize how awesome it was until I watched the videos, especially the longer ones explaining the basic features and outlining. Amazing transformation.

    Something clicked when I bought it this past fall – and now its totally indispensable! Great review and welcome to the convert’s club. 🙂

    Thanks! Yes, I’m a total convert. There’s nothing else like it, and for the price, it’s really unbeatable.

  5. So my subscription for Office 365 runs out today and I’m more than pissed on spending 100 something big ones on a program that is less than sophisticated to a cali valley girl. Is Scrivener the answer to my mere word processing needs or will this program not work for college student finishing his assignments and veer more toward a novelist? Kinda confused here.

    Hi, Paul, and welcome. Scrivener comes with a lot of templates – A LOT of them. There’s one for a thesis and research paper, and for plays, scripts, and yes, novels. If you think you need one of those, Scrivener fits the bill. You can do a LOT with it. But, if you’re more interested in simple word processing needs, and want some of the classic features of Microsoft Office without the huge price tag, try LibreOffice. It’s absolutely free. You can download it here. Good luck!

Hey, what's up? Tell me whatcha think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s